November 19, 2026
On March 27, a 4,370-square-foot home on North Firewood Drive in Candlewood went on the market at $1,325,000. It closed on May 8 for $1,307,000, about six weeks after listing and at 98.6% of its asking price. A few doors away on North Candlewood Drive, a 6,312-square-foot home with a pool and a finished basement had come on the market the previous October at $1,699,000. It closed two days before the Firewood house for $1,420,000.
The two homes are in the same subdivision and closed in the same week. The larger one had almost 2,000 more square feet and sold for $113,000 more. Those extra feet came to about $57 each, well below what buyers paid per foot for the rest of either house. Three closings are a small sample, but in each of Candlewood's 2026 sales the extra square footage added less to the price than the lot, the location and the condition of the main living space did.
Candlewood is a 59-lot subdivision about a mile north of the Crossover Road and Mission Boulevard intersection in east Fayetteville. Its main entrance is off Crossover, which is Arkansas Highway 265. Developer Tom Terminella put it together in 1998 and 1999 from two land purchases totaling $975,000, a 41.2-acre tract of rolling ground with mature white and red oaks. The headwaters of Mud Creek run along its east side, according to a 2005 Talk Business & Politics profile.
The lots range from 0.42 to 1.38 acres, and the first ones sold for $70,000 to $95,000. Terminella said most of them trended toward the larger end of that range to make room for bigger homes. Gary Combs of Basic Construction built the roads and designed the brick entrance off Crossover, and he told the same publication the entrance work cost about $250,000. Terminella described the plan with less ceremony: "There's no particular trendy theme, just a lot of people building half-million-dollar houses."
Those homes were built large from the start, and the smallest Candlewood house to close this year still had 3,571 square feet. With every neighbor already sizable, square footage alone does little to set one house apart. The lot it sits on, its condition and the way it was priced do more of that work.
Three Candlewood homes closed between January and October 2026, according to MLS records.
| Address | Living area | Sold price | Price per sq. ft. | Share of final list price | Closed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2670 N Candlewood Drive | 6,312 sq. ft. | $1,420,000 | $224 | 94.7% | May 6, 2026 |
| 2599 N Firewood Drive | 4,370 sq. ft. | $1,307,000 | $299 | 98.6% | May 8, 2026 |
| 2567 N Firewood Drive | 3,571 sq. ft. | $964,000 | $269 | 91.9% | Oct 8, 2026 |
Taken together, those three homes sold for an average of 95.1% of their final list prices in 2026. The largest one brought the lowest price per square foot. The middle-sized one brought the highest price per square foot and sold fastest. The smallest one came in between on price per foot and spent roughly four months on the market.
The home at 2670 N Candlewood Drive has a lot that could be in any Candlewood listing photo. Its 0.80 acre holds a 40-by-17-foot heated Gunite pool, a firepit and a deck. Inside are a finished basement with media and billiards rooms and a bar, plus a kitchen with a six-burner gas cooktop, a double oven and a wine refrigerator. It went on the market October 10, 2025, at $1,699,000. The price was reduced on January 14, and the home closed May 6 at $1,420,000, about 84% of where it started.
At $224 a square foot, that sale came in almost exactly at Fayetteville's citywide average. The Skyline Report from the University of Arkansas Center for Business and Economic Research put that average at $223.88 for houses sold in the first half of 2026. So a large, amenity-heavy house on nearly an acre in Candlewood sold at the same rate per foot as the average Fayetteville home that spring. The Firewood house that closed two days later sold for $75 more per foot.
A basement media room, a billiards room and a heated pool cost real money to build. The 2026 closings show buyers were willing to pay for them, though not at the rate per foot that the main floors of a Candlewood home bring. For a seller with a large home here, the first list price matters more than it would on a smaller house. In this case, almost four months passed between the price change and the closing.
The home at 2567 N Firewood Drive is the smallest of the three. It sits on 0.34 acre, and the house was renovated in 2018. The renovation updated the kitchen and primary bath and added a covered patio with an outdoor fireplace that looks onto a private backyard. It closed October 8 for $964,000, or $269 a square foot. It sold for 91.9% of its final list price after roughly four months on the market.
This house brought $45 more per square foot than the 6,312-square-foot home on Candlewood Drive. The likely reason is the updated kitchen and primary bath, the rooms buyers tend to price most heavily. Its time on the market and its gap between list and sale price were in line with a fall market where buyers at this level had plenty to compare.
For anyone looking at a Candlewood home built around 2000, the same lesson applies from the other side. A well-built, original-condition house on a good lot gives you something to work with. The 2026 sales suggest buyers pay more per foot for updated main living spaces than for extra rooms, so a renovation plan aimed at the kitchen, baths and outdoor living space matches how this neighborhood has priced homes this year.
The citywide market gives these three sales some context. In the first half of 2026, Fayetteville recorded 660 home sales at an average price of $432,635 and a median of $379,900, with an average of 95 days on market. The Skyline Report groups every sale above $500,000 into one band. That band had 157 sales from January through June, or 23.8% of the city's total. Those homes averaged 2,826 square feet and 102 days on market, and they sold for 98.3% of list price on average.
When the report was released on August 21, CBER Director Mervin Jebaraj told Talk Business & Politics that "for the first time in many years, I would characterize this as more of a buyer's market than a seller's market." He also said large-scale homebuilders were offering incentives and mortgage rate buy-downs to sell their new homes. The same article put Washington County's average sale price at $423,750 for the first half of 2026, up 1.5% from a year earlier.
Candlewood's three closings averaged 95.1% of list this year, while Fayetteville's $500,000-plus band averaged 98.3% in the first half. That gap matches what Jebaraj described. Buyers in this price range have choices, including new construction with financing incentives. A home on a half-acre under 25-year-old oaks, a mile from Crossover and Mission, has things a buyer values. Those things still have to be priced against everything else a buyer at $1 million can see that week.
The 2005 profile included a lot-by-lot record of Candlewood's early sales, and comparing it with today's prices shows how much of the value sits in the land and its location. The home at 2607 N Candlewood Drive was built in 2000 and sold that year for $450,000. It closed on October 6, 2025, for $1,900,000, the highest of the four Candlewood sales since last fall. The lot at 2670 N Candlewood Drive was bought in 2003 for $93,000, and its building permits totaled $412,000. That is a little over half a million dollars in land and permits for a home that sold this May for $1,420,000.
The larger lots have stayed at the top of the market. In 2003, Barber Properties paid $110,000 for a 1.2-acre lot at 3122 Township Road, at the edge of the subdivision. A 7,081-square-foot home at 3122 E Township St has been listed at $2,750,000. Closer in, 2529 N Candlewood Drive, a 3,508-square-foot home with a hot tub and peaceful views, was listed at $1,250,000 through much of 2026. Both list prices are asking prices. The closings above show how far apart asking and selling prices can get here.
If you own a Candlewood home and are thinking about selling, start by comparing it with the 4,370-square-foot Firewood home that closed about six weeks after listing, not the largest sale. That house listed near what the market would pay and closed at 98.6% of its asking price. Price per square foot from a much larger or much smaller neighbor will mislead you in both directions, because extra footage in this neighborhood has added less to the price than the base of the house has. Updated kitchens, baths and outdoor living space have shown up in the price. A finished basement and a pool also added value, but less per foot than the main living space.
If you are relocating and comparing Candlewood with newer subdivisions, it helps to see the 2026 numbers plainly. A larger Candlewood house can sell at roughly Fayetteville's average price per square foot. When a listing has been on the market a while, sellers here have accepted meaningful reductions. Builders across the region are competing with incentives, and in the first half of 2026 Fayetteville's market leaned toward buyers. You can read more about the area on our Candlewood neighborhood page and our Fayetteville overview.
If you're weighing what your Candlewood home might bring, or whether a 2000-era home off Crossover Road deserves a place on your list, I'd love to go through these sales with you, house by house. At Becky Carter Realtor, we can talk through what you want from your next home alongside what these numbers show. You can begin with a home valuation request, or reach out directly. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Buying and selling a home is a big decision. One should feel that they have a dedicated and highly-qualified partner every step of the way. Maybe you’re single, married, a single parent, or an investor. Maybe you’re looking to buy new construction or a fixer-upper. Whatever the case, I’m here to serve you. With attention to detail, a love of design, a commitment to personal service, and a belief that faith and family thrive in the right space, I’ll either help you find the home that best fits your needs or I will help you prepare to market your home to the most qualified buyers.